The platform you sell on is one of the most consequential financial decisions in e-commerce. Fee differences of 3–5% per sale compound into thousands of dollars annually at volume. But fees alone do not determine profitability — buyer intent, conversion rate, and audience fit matter just as much.
This comparison uses verified 2026 fee schedules to model the true cost of selling on Etsy, Amazon, Shopify, eBay, and TikTok Shop — with real net-profit examples at $20, $40, and $80 price points for US sellers.
Fee Structure Comparison — 2026
| Platform | Core Fee | Monthly | Listing | Processing | True Take (no ads) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🛍 Etsy | 6.5% transaction (incl. shipping) | $0 | $0.20/item | 3% + $0.25 | ~9.5–10.5% |
| 📦 Amazon Individual | 8–15% referral (category-based) | $0 | $0.99/item | Included in referral | 9–16% + $0.99 |
| 📦 Amazon Professional | 8–15% referral | $39.99 | $0 | Included | 8–15% + $39.99/mo |
| 🏪 Shopify Basic | 0% (Shopify Payments) | $29 | $0 | 2.9% + $0.30 | 2.9% + $0.30 + $29/mo |
| 🛒 eBay Standard | 13.25% final value fee | $0 | Free (250/mo) | Included | ~13.25% |
| 🎵 TikTok Shop | 6% referral | $0 | $0 | 2.5% + $0.30 | ~8.5% |
Net Profit Model — $40 Handmade Item
Inputs: $40 item price, $6 shipping charged to buyer, $5 actual shipping cost, $12 cost of goods. No advertising fees. Standard 2026 rates.
| Platform | Total Fees | Net Profit | Margin on Item Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 🛍 Etsy (no Offsite Ads) | $5.36 | $23.64 | 59.1% |
| 🎵 TikTok Shop (direct sale) | $4.09 | $24.91 | 62.3% |
| 📦 Amazon Individual (10% ref) | $4.99 + $0.99 | $22.02 | 55.1% |
| 🛒 eBay | $6.10 | $22.90 | 57.3% |
| 🏪 Shopify Basic (100 sales/mo) | $1.76 + $0.29/sale | ~$26.95 after monthly amort. | 67.4% |
When Etsy Is the Right Platform
Etsy's fee structure is competitive with Amazon for most product types, and its buyer base actively searches for handmade, vintage, and unique items with purchase intent that other platforms cannot replicate.
- Handmade and craft products — Etsy buyers specifically seek these and will pay premium prices. The same item on Amazon competes against mass-produced alternatives at a fraction of the price.
- Vintage and collectibles — Etsy's dedicated vintage category attracts motivated buyers who have already decided to spend on the category before they arrive.
- Digital downloads — Zero shipping cost and Etsy's infrastructure for automatic delivery makes it the best platform for printables, templates, and digital products. The fee structure at $10–15 price points is workable even with 3% + $0.25 processing applied.
- Lower-volume sellers — No monthly fee and no minimum sales requirement makes Etsy lower-risk than Shopify for sellers moving under 50 units per month.
When Amazon Is the Better Choice
- Mass-market products — Amazon's search volume for commodity and popular products dwarfs Etsy. If you are selling a product that does not require handmade positioning, Amazon's reach is unmatched.
- High-volume sellers — Amazon Professional at $39.99/month becomes cost-effective above roughly 40 sales per month when compared to the $0.99/item Individual plan.
- Products benefiting from Prime — FBA fulfillment and Prime eligibility dramatically improve conversion for categories where fast shipping is a primary purchase driver.
When Shopify Is the Better Choice
- Brand-first businesses — Shopify gives you complete control over the customer experience, email list ownership, and repeat purchase mechanics that marketplace platforms do not allow.
- High-volume sellers — Above 200–300 monthly orders, Shopify's $29/month amortizes to under $0.15 per order and the 2.9% + $0.30 processing rate becomes very competitive.
- Subscription and repeat purchase products — Shopify's native tools for subscriptions, loyalty programs, and email marketing make it the better long-term infrastructure investment for brands with strong repeat customer economics.
The Multi-Platform Answer
The highest-revenue handmade and artisan sellers in 2026 typically use Etsy as their primary discovery channel — where buyers find them organically — and their own Shopify store as the direct channel where they capture email addresses, run subscriptions, and build customer relationships outside Etsy's control.
This hybrid model uses Etsy's traffic and audience targeting to acquire customers and then moves repeat buyers to a lower-fee direct channel over time. The total effective fee rate across the portfolio drops as the Shopify share of revenue grows.
Calculate Your Etsy Profit
Enter your real numbers to see exact fees and net profit for your specific product.
Open Fee Calculator →